Book publishing can be inherently political, as it involves the dissemination of ideas, perspectives, and stories that can influence public opinion and shape societal narratives. The political nature of book publishing becomes apparent in several aspects, from representation, censorship, and intellectual freedom to readership influence, content/themes, and editorial decisions.
As reported by Publishers Weekly in an October 17, 2023, article, the Frankfurt Book Fair held its opening press conference under the shadow of a controversy that resulted in numerous Arab publishing associations pulling out of the fair in protest of its decision to postpone the 2023 LiBeraturpreis award ceremony honoring Berlin-based Palestinian author Adania Shibli. Indonesia and Malaysia pulled out of the fair, followed by several Arab, Egyptian, and Muslim speakers and authors. More than 1,100 authors and publishing personalities signed an open letter of protest published on arablit.org.
In the ever-changing landscape of the publishing industry, the Frankfurt Book Fair has long been hailed as a melting pot of literary minds, a space where cultures collide and ideas are born. However, 2023’s fair being cast into the shadow of controversy highlights two fundamental truths: publishing is political, and it has always been political.
As the CEO of Fruition Publishing and a proud member of the IBPA Board of Directors, I have always maintained that understanding, and navigating the political currents in our industry is not just an option but a necessity. The recent events at the Frankfurt Book Fair underscore this point vividly.
The Power of Political Awareness
Publishing, at its core, is about storytelling. For independent publishers, it is also about giving voice to the unheard, which includes marginalized communities and challenging the status quo. In this pursuit, it is impossible to separate the industry from the political landscape it operates within. Books have been banned, censored, and celebrated based on political ideologies for centuries. The Frankfurt Book Fair incident is merely a recent example of the industry’s political underpinnings coming to the forefront once again.
The decision of Arab publishing associations to boycott the fair was a powerful statement, resonating far beyond the exhibition halls. It showcased the industry’s role as a platform for social and political discourse, a catalyst for change. As publishing professionals, we must recognize this power and wield it responsibly.
Case Study #1: The Role of Literature in Social Movements
Historically, literature has played a pivotal role in social and political movements. Take the Civil Rights Movement in the United States, where books like To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee and The Autobiography of Malcolm X by Malcolm X and Alex Haley served as catalysts for change. These works challenged societal norms and sparked crucial conversations, underscoring the political power of storytelling. It should come as no surprise that these books are currently on the banned list.
Case Study #2: The Impact of Banned Books
Speaking of book bans, consider the case of British-Indian author Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses. Banned in several countries due to its controversial content, this book ignited discussions about freedom of expression, religion, and cultural sensitivity. Publishers and readers stood in solidarity with Rushdie, emphasizing the industry’s role as a battleground for fundamental rights and political ideologies.
Embracing Diversity and Inclusion
In an increasingly interconnected world, the call for diversity and inclusion in publishing has grown louder. Readers demand stories that reflect their realities, cultures, and experiences. Publishers and authors who heed this call recognize the political implications of their work. Embracing diversity is not just a trend but a moral and political imperative. By publishing diverse voices, we challenge prejudices, break down barriers, and foster empathy.
The Frankfurt Book Fair incident serves as a stark reminder that inclusivity is not just about the stories we publish but also about the authors we celebrate and the platforms we endorse. Supporting diverse voices is not a passive act; it is a political stance against discrimination and inequality.
Strategic Preparedness: Navigating Political Waters
In the face of political turbulence, publishing professionals must be strategic in their approach. This involves understanding the nuances of cultural sensitivities, being aware of geopolitical tensions, and recognizing the impact of global events on the industry. A reactive stance is no longer sufficient. Proactive engagement with political issues is essential to anticipate challenges and mitigate potential risks.
Furthermore, publishers and authors alike must be prepared to take a stand on matters that align with their values. Silence, too, is a political statement. By staying neutral in the face of injustice, we inadvertently become complicit. Publishing professionals have a moral obligation to use their platforms to promote understanding, tolerance, and social change.
So, how can we navigate publishing’s political waters with confidence? I recommend the following four actions:
1. Cultivate Cultural Competence
Publishing professionals must educate themselves about diverse cultures, religions, and political landscapes. Engaging with sensitivity readers and diverse beta readers will help to ensure authenticity and avoid cultural misrepresentation. Building a culturally competent team fosters an inclusive environment and aids in respectful storytelling.
2. Embrace Intersectionality
Recognize that identities are multifaceted. Authors and publishers must amplify voices that represent various intersections of identity, including race, gender, sexual orientation, and socioeconomic background. Intersectional storytelling not only enriches the literary landscape but also promotes social and political understanding.
3. Advocate for Intellectual Freedom
Stand against censorship and support organizations like the American Library Association’s Office for Intellectual Freedom. Engage in campaigns defending the freedom to read and publish. By advocating for intellectual freedom, publishing professionals safeguard the industry’s political independence and contribute to a more democratic society.
4. Amplify Marginalized Voices
Publishers can actively seek out and publish authors from marginalized communities. Establish initiatives, mentorship programs, and grants specifically aimed at empowering underrepresented voices. Amplifying these voices challenges the existing power structures and promotes political awareness within the industry. (Sidenote: This is one of the reasons I love IBPA and its forward-thinking industry action. The launch of the Innovative Voices Program, which I had the privilege of working on, is a bold step in the right direction, especially in times like these.)
The Way Forward: A Unified Industry
The events surrounding the Frankfurt Book Fair remind us that publishing is a powerful force that can shape public opinion and influence societal norms. As we navigate the intricate web of politics and publishing, it is imperative to recognize that our actions reverberate far beyond the confines of bookshelves. By embracing the political nature of our industry, understanding the power dynamics at play, cultivating cultural competence, embracing intersectionality, advocating for intellectual freedom, and amplifying marginalized voices, we can actively shape a more inclusive and politically aware publishing industry.
The Frankfurt Book Fair incident serves as a call to action for all publishing professionals. Let us embark on this transformative journey together, armed with knowledge, empathy, and a deep commitment to social and political progress. Let us commit to fostering an industry that celebrates diversity, challenges injustice, and promotes unity. Let us stand together, authors, publishers, and readers alike, as advocates for a more inclusive, empathetic, and politically aware world.
By navigating the political seas with wisdom and compassion, we can steer our industry toward a future where diverse voices are celebrated, societal injustices are challenged, and the transformative power of literature knows no bounds. Let us seize this moment to reaffirm our commitment to the fundamental principles of equality, justice, and the transformative power of storytelling. Together, we can navigate the choppy waters of publishing and steer our industry toward a brighter, more inclusive future.
Alesha Brown is the founder and CEO of Fruition Publishing Concierge Services®, a hybrid publisher devoted to helping authors find their voice, monetize their expertise, and create profitable author platforms. Brown currently serves on the IBPA DEI Committee and IBPA Board of Directors.